HER BRAIN MADE HER DO THE MURDER...as, in fact, we are all radically unfree and enslaved by our neural networks. In the argument raging over this form of special pleading in the criminal courts of Italy, one may find the history (or, perhaps, the revival) of the argument between "free will" and "determinism." The U.K. Guardian does rather well in summarizing this instance of the return of one of the three irreducible philosophical disputes.